9 Custom Cookies To Order Online

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Birthdays, baby and bridal showers, Mother’s Day, graduations, holidays and weddings will all be a little sweeter with custom cookies made just for you. 

In this article, you’ll discover some amazing bakeries that take online orders and ship or deliver decorated cookies right to your door. 

Every occasion calls for a different type of cookie and personalization. We included all types of fun custom cookies in this roundup.

So whether you’re ordering something extra special for a kid’s birthday party, need the highest quality cookies for a wedding or need a cute cookie to celebrate a baby shower, you’ll be able to find some fun options here.

Gourmet Custom Cookies To Order Online

The Best Custom Cookies To Order Online

1. BEST COOKIE BOUQUETS & GIFT BASKETS

Cookies By Design

Hand-Made Cookie Bouquets, Baskets, and Gifts For Any and All Occasions. Same Day Delivery Available.

Just as their name suggests, Cookies By Design takes pride in being Cookies “by Design”. As you browse the website, you’ll see they have many unique designs and messages to choose from.

Cookies By Design Hand Decorated Cookie Bouquet

But this business is more than happy to personalize or customize your cookie gift to make it perfect for your special event or occasion.

Whether you want a special message, particular colors or a different theme, you can provide your details and work with their designers to create the perfect treat.

Products Available From Cookies By Design

The list of treats you can order from Cookies By Design is impressive.

Cookie Arrangements

Choose from cookie bouquets, baskets and something called a boutray. It is the perfect cookie combination. It combines a sugar cookie bouquet and a tray of delicious gourmet cookies to create a unique gourmet gift basket

They also have a Build-A-Bear bouquet. These fun bouquets are available through a partnership with the Build-A-Bear company. With this bouquet, a soft Happy Hugs bear is surrounded by signature handmade decorated cookies.

Cookies By Design Build A Bear Cookie Bouquet

Specialty Cookies

These delicious cookie gifts come in a variety of packaging such as boxes, tins, platters and gift baskets. Some of the flavors available include red velvet, chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia nut, oatmeal raisin, decadent chocolate and millionaire cookies.

You can also shop for fun decorating kits, cookie favors, cookie cakes and cookie trays for literally every occasion.

Specialty Gifts

If you need extra special treats, you’ll be interested in their specialty options. Gourmet brownies, pro sports cookie gifts, chocolate truffles and custom photo cookie gifts.

Corporate cookie gifts are also available.

Ordering Information

Visit the Cookies By Design website to place an order online for nationwide delivery.


2. BEST COOKIES IN A CUSTOM TIN

Christie Cookie Co

This Nashville bakery offers handcrafted treats with custom options that are perfect for gift-giving. Christie Cookie Co was voted “Best Cookie in the South” by Southern Living Magazine.

Christie Cookie Co - Cookies and Brownies

Christie Cookie Co offers 3 delicious signature cookie flavors that they have perfected over the years. Choose from chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia nut and oatmeal raisin.

This bakery offers a slightly different custom option than some of the others on our list. You can make your Christie Cookie order extra sweet by designing a custom tin for your cookie to go in.

Christie Cookie Co Custom Tin

The website makes it easy to create your own tin. First, pick your size and tin color. You can add an optional border and upload your own artwork.

If you’re not feeling that creative, you can also pick from some of their designs for special occasions and events to celebrate like birthday, thank you and congratulations.

They also have tins designed to celebrate a variety of college and professional sports teams from the south.

Christie Cookie Location
Nashville, TN

Ordering Information
Order cookies online for nationwide shipping. Nashville store locations and information about local delivery are also available on the Christie Cookie website.


3. MOST FUN CUSTOM COOKIES

Baked In Color

The Happiest Cookies On Earth! Every cookie is rolled and twisted by hand to create rainbow and custom colored cookies.

Baked In Color Cookies - Best Mail Order Cookies to Order Online

These fun cookies have been featured in the Huffington Post, Delish and the Today Show.

Baked In Color offers a variety of standard offerings like their famous Rainbow Chocolate Chip Cookie, Giant Rainbow Oreo Brownies, and Huge Cookie Cakes.

This bakery also has a great variety of sweet treats that you can customize with your own colors. You’ll want to check out their “Choose Your Own Colors” chocolate chip cookie cake and chocolate chip cookie gift tin.

Baked In Color Custom Rainbow Cookie Cake

During the checkout process, you can select from a variety of standard colors like red, green and orange. Or you can get more creative with colors like turquoise, maroon, violet or even gold!

The College Colors Chocolate Chip Cookies Gift Tin is also pretty great. Pick from a list of about 40 major colleges and you’ll get custom cookies that celebrate your college colors.

Baked In Color Location
New York, NY

Ordering Information
Order your custom cookies online from Goldbelly for nationwide shipping.


4. MOST OPTIONS FOR CUSTOM COOKIES

Etsy Custom & Personalized Cookies

Thousands of Delicious Options Delivered To Your Door

Etsy is a global marketplace for unique and creative goods from independent sellers around the world. Many people think of Etsy as a place to find items like handmade crafts or vintage clothing.

But Etsy is also an excellent place to find custom cookie makers from around the globe. 

You may also like: Food-scented Candles From Etsy

Etsy Custom Cookies
Credit: Etsy

Available Decorated Cookie Designs and Options:

A search for “custom cookies” on Etsy generates over 34,000 results!

There are convenient subcategories like custom cookies for graduation, birthday party, baby shower, wedding, engagements, bridal showers, and bridesmaid. These categories make it super easy to find the perfect cookie for any occasion.

With such a variety of vendors to choose from, the design options are endless. You can design cookies with a logo or with a picture. Or maybe you’re looking for cookies with a photo, photo collage, or even with your face! 

Etsy Custom Cookies
Image: Etsy

Location

Etsy vendors are located around the world. You can also easily filter by prices, shipping options, and top customer reviews. 

Ordering Information

To order cookies from Etsy, first browse for keywords like custom cookies or personalized cookies.  Next, narrow your options with filters or subcategories. 


5. BEST DIY (DO IT YOURSELF) CUSTOM COOKIES

Color My Cookie

Create one-of-a-kind custom decorated cookies at-home

It’s hard to get more custom than a design you create yourself!

These cookie decorating kits come with a pre-iced cookie for a perfectly smooth canvas. The artisan cookies are hand-cut and baked by professional pastry chefs. The classic shortbread cookies are made with just 5 simple ingredients: flour, butter, sugar, eggs and vanilla.

Color My Cookie Custom Decorating Kit Hearts
Image: Color My Cookie

Each kit also comes with edible watercolors, paintbrushes, icing, sprinkles, fondant decorations and an online tutorial.

The kits come in a wide variety of styles so there is something for kids (and grownups) of all ages and interests. Browse through the options and you’ll find everything from princesses and unicorns to pirates and dinos.

Color My Cookie Custom Decorating Kit Superhero Boys
Image: Color My Cookie

There are also seasonal kits, several options for birthdays and even a home sweet home kit that would make a great housewarming gift.

Ordering Information

Cookie decorating kits can be ordered online and shipped nationwide.


6. HIGHEST QUALITY GOURMET CUSTOM COOKIES

Sugarica

Gourmet Decorated Sugar Cookies Personalized For Your Occasion

The attention to detail of Sugarica cookies is the best we’ve seen. If you are looking for gorgeous, high-quality cookies, look no further than Sugarica.

The sugar cookies are delicious, thick, buttery and cake-like. They are made with the highest quality ingredients including 100% real butter. No other shortening, high-fructose corn syrup, vegetable oil, or preservatives, ever!

Sugarica Everyday Cookies
Image: Sugarica Cookies

Sugarica has a variety of beautiful cookies in their “everyday products” collection that can be ordered and shipped within 1-2 days of order. 

They also specialize in custom orders for bridal showers, baby showers, and birthday parties. In addition, they offer logo cookies and Iconic Face Cookies which are taking over as the custom cookie gourmet gift of choice!

Iconic Face Cookie Sugarica Cookies
Image: Sugarica Cookies

Their artists are experienced pastry designers that will work with you to design the perfect cookie for your occasion. A two-week notice is requested for custom orders.

Our Thoughts: 

We were lucky enough to try some Sugarica Cookies. They are drop-dead gorgeous. The attention to detail on the royal icing is amazing.  The designs are intricate and the colors are so vibrant. 

We can also attest that they taste as good as they look! The cookies are thick and buttery, with just the right amount of sweetness. 

Sugarica Cookies
Samples from Sugarica Cookies

Sugarica Location

Sugarica is located in San Luis Obispo, CA. They offer free local delivery within a 50-mile radius. 

Ordering Information

Each cookie order can also be shipped within the US. All cookies are made fresh the week of shipping or delivery. Cookies are packaged in heat-sealed bags for freshness. They will stay fresh for 2-3 weeks unopened. 

To order online or for more information, visit the Sugarica website


7. BEST CUSTOMIZED COOKIE SHOTS

The Dirty Cookie

Fun little cookies shaped like a shot glass!

The Dirty Cookie Customized Cookie Shots
Image: The Dirty Cookie

Everyone knows cookies are great to dunk in milk. The Dirty Cookie decided that if cookies can go in milk, why can’t milk go in the cookie!

These customizable Cookie Shots are actually delicious cookies shaped like a little glass so you can add your favorites inside.

All you do is warm it in the microwave for a few seconds, then fill it up with milk, coffee, ice cream, milkshake, sweet liquor or anything else that strikes your fancy.

The company offers pre-decorated shots, but you can also decorate your own with their DIY kits. They have all sorts of options and themes: baby shower, happy birthday, unicorn, mermaid, summer, winter, graduation, Christmas, football and even one for dog lovers!

**Use code SNACKATEERS15 for 15% off your order!**


8. BEST KEEPSAKE COOKIES

Sugarworks Cookies 

A Delicious Little Cookie Studio

At Sugarworks Cookies, every thick and buttery cookie is baked to order from scratch, handmade, and hand-decorated.

Cookies have an edible shelf life of 30-45 days when kept in original packaging. And believe it or not, they also keep indefinitely as a keepsake!

The sugar cookie ingredients are simple: flour, cane sugar, fresh butter, farm-fresh eggs, pure vanilla extract and sea salt. You can’t beat fresh and simple!

Sugarworks Balloon Cookies
Image: Sugarworks Cookies

Available Designs and Options:

Sugarworks Cookies offers custom cookie favors for occasions like weddings and baby showers. They also offer cookie platters for an event or can even be shipped to a client.

Cookie favors are individually wrapped in a clear cellophane bag and tied for a festive presentation. You can also send labels, ribbons, or stickers that Sugarworks will attach at no extra cost. 

Cookie platters include a variety of whimsical cookies. A clear platter is included for pick up orders only. If cookies are being shipped, they are individually bagged and heat-sealed to ensure safe shipping. 

Sugarworks Summer BBQ Cookies
Image: Sugarworks Cookies

Sugarworks Location:

The cookies are made in a licensed New Jersey commercial bakery (not a retail store). 

Ordering Information

Orders can be placed online or by phone.


9. BEST COOKIE COLLECTIONS

Southern Sugar Bakery

A Premier Decorated Cookie Company

Southern Sugar Bakery is a premier custom cookie decorator. They specialize in detailed designs for weddings, birthdays, holidays, and corporate events.

Southern Sugar Birthday Cookies
Image: Southern Sugar Bakery

Available Designs and Options: 

The bakery features dozens of gorgeous designs for every occasion. Their website is very easy to use to find the perfect cookie you’re looking for.

Just click on a category like “child birthday” or “baby events” and you’ll get plenty of options to choose from.

Some of their other design categories include sports, teacher appreciation, graduation, new home, get well and sympathy, Communion and Baptism, and school events. 

They also offer a corporate event set that features a custom logo of your choosing.

Southern Sugar Wedding Cookies
Image: Southern Sugar Cookies

Southern Sugar Bakery Location:

Southern Sugar Bakery is located in Raleigh, North Carolina. Cookie orders can be picked up from the bakery, or shipped anywhere in the United States. 

Ordering Information

Visit the Southern Sugar website to place an order.


BONUS: BEST CUSTOM BROWNIE

West Coast Confections

Indulgent, gourmet, MASSIVE brownies, blondies, and cookies

I know, I know. This is a list about cookies. But it’s not often you come across a bakery that lets you customize your own gourmet brownie!

If you have an event or celebration that needs a really special custom treat with a personal touch, you might want to consider these brownies.

You can really let your imagination run wild. They don’t even give you options to pick from. You literally just fill in a form on the website with details you can think of.

But if you need some inspiration, you can browse through photos of other people’s creations like this pineapple upside down blondie!

West Coast Confection Custom Brownie Blondie
Image: West Coast Confections

MORE COOKIE FUN
Moonshine Mountain Cookie Review – Cookies made with real moonshine!
Best Cookie Cakes To Order Online
Oreo Cookie Pie Recipe
Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe


Save it for later on Pinterest, Instagram and Facebook. Also join our Facebook Group for more snack fun!

Gourmet Custom Cookies (1)

 

You may also be interested in: 

Best Gourmet Brownies For Delivery
Snack Subscription Boxes