Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company Review (2021)

This post is sponsored by the Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company.

Have you ever tried a gourmet cookie infused with real Tennessee Moonshine? If your mouth is watering at the idea, you’ll want to check out the Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company.

With 7 regular flavors on the menu and several more seasonal options, these hand-crafted cookies are sure to please every palate. And best of all, you can ship these cookies nationwide to get your cookie fix any time, any place.

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Logo

About Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company

It all began back in 1988 in Knoxville, Tennesee. The Moonshine Mountain cookie recipe was actually formulated as a sweet treat for the owner’s pizza delivery business. Customers loved the cookies and asked for more.

Fast forward to the present day and you’ll find the fast-growing moonshine cookie empire that is the Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company.

These gourmet cookies are hand-crafted in small batches using the highest-quality ingredients. Many of the recipes include a slash of real Tennesee Moonshine.

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Flavors

The Moonshine Mountain Cookie company takes pride in the quality of their cookies … and the names of their cookies! Just check out these awesome flavors on the regular menu.

Moonshine Mountain Cookies Menu

Caramel By The Sea

This award-winning cookie has caramel bits, chocolate-coated toffee, sea salt sprinkles and is infused with butterscotch moonshine. It was awarded the “The Best Cookie in the State of Tennesee” by thedailymeal.com. I agree with the honor – it’s a really great cookie!

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Caramel By The Sea Flavor
Caramel By The Sea Cookie

Berry White

This sweet treat includes real strawberries, white chocolate, and a splash of strawberry moonshine.

Rocky Top

The spin on this classic chocolate chip cookie is the addition of golden rolled oats for a bit of extra heartiness and texture.

Moonshine Mountain Rocky Top Chocolate Chip Cookie
Rocky Top Cookie

Choco Khan

This cookie is for the chocolate lover. It’s a chocolate cookie with milk, semi-sweet and dark chocolate morsels, chunks, and shavings.

Sugar Shine

The familiar favorite sugar cookie is amped up a notch in this version with white chocolate, pure cane sugar, some confetti sprinkles on top and a splash of moonshine.

Happy Pappy

Another cookie infused with moonshine! This cookie has chunks of real apple, white chocolate, and of course, a splash of Apple Pie Moonshine.

Moonshine Mountain Happy Pappy Apple Pie Moonshine Cookie
Happy Pappy Cookie

Nutty Butty Holly

Heads up, peanut butter fans! This cookie is packed with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, swirls of creamy chocolate and rolled oats.

John Lennon

Whole blueberries and zesty lemon flavor create beautiful music together in this cookie that works equally well as a dessert or breakfast.


Moonshine Mountain Cookies Review

Now that your mouth is watering, I’ll give you a quick review of the flavors that I’ve tried. The folks at Moonshine Mount Cookies were kind enough to send me a box of cookies to sample.

Moonshine Mountain Cookies Box

Packaging

My box of a dozen cookies included 3 flavors: Rocky Top, Caramel By The Sea and Happy Pappy. The package arrived with a sturdy outer shipping box. The cookies were nestled inside in a separate brown bakery box.

In the photo below, you can see the handy little card included in the package. It lists every cookie flavor available, along with the ingredients and allergen info. The flavors included in your package will have a hand-written checkmark in the box. I thought this was a nice little, personal touch.

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Menu

Each flavor in the box is packaged separately and very clearly labeled.

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Package Label

Taste-Testing

The package also included a ‘cookie care’ card that suggested popping the cookies in the microwave for a few seconds for a ‘fresh from the oven’ taste and texture. I highly recommend you take this advice!

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Instructions

The cookies are great straight from the package, but wow, they are over-the-top, ooey-gooey delicious when they are warmed up. My Caramel By The Sea Cookie turned into a little molten caramel volcano. So good!

One thing I absolutely loved about these cookies is the shape. Every cookie is about the same size, but the shape is totally unique. You can tell each cookie is hand-scooped and made by a person, not a machine.

Moonshine Mountain Cookie Caramel Flavor
Caramel By The Sea Cookie

The cookie texture is great too. The thinner edges are slightly crispy. The thicker cookie middle is more dense, moist and slightly chewier. Just a great combination of textures. These are fun cookies to eat.

And last but not least, the taste. The Rocky Top Chocolate Chip Cookie was a hearty, stick to your ribs kind of cookie. Very satisfying.

I had a grin on my face the whole time I was sampling the Happy Pappy cookie. It’s hard not to giggle when you’re getting moonshine and apple pie in cookie form!

My favorite of the bunch was the award-winning Caramel By The Sea. It was just the right amount of buttery sweetness from the caramel plus little pops of saltiness. If you’re a caramel fan, I highly recommend trying this flavor.


Customer Reviews

It’s always nice to hear about the experience other customers have had too. A quick google search revealed lots of great feedback about Moonshine Mountain Cookies.

Here are a few of the helpful comments we found. Even more awesome is that the company took the time to reply to every customer.

“These cookies put all the others to shame!”

“These cookies are absolutely fabulous. There’s a flavor for everyone.”

“Amazing! A little crispy on the outside and doughy in the middle.”

As with all things in life, you can’t please everyone. One customer mentioned they liked the unique shape of the cookies and the great customer service, but that the “Cookies seem to be an oatmeal base with just various ingredients added depending on flavor.”

This is a valid point. All of the cookies we tried did contain oats. We personally liked the texture the oats added but can appreciate they may not be for everyone.

Overall, the vast majority of customers rated these cookies as excellent or very good.


Moonshine Mountain Cookies Shipping Policy

All cookies are baked and shipped fresh from the Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company kitchens. To ensure freshness and to prevent your cookies from sitting in a shipping warehouse over the weekend, they have a few policies in place.

When Your Order Will Ship

If you order before 1PM EST, Monday-Wednesday, and your cookies will be baked fresh & shipped the same day. Orders placed after that will be baked fresh and shipped the following Monday.

Overnight Shipping

Also, if you need your cookies guaranteed to arrive on a specific day, Moonshine Mountain recommends the overnight shipping option should be used.

Nationwide Shipping Zones

A shipping map is available on their website. If your order is shipping outside the standard 1-2 day delivery zone, an expedited delivery option is suggested.

For more details, visit the Shipping Information page on the company website.


How To Contact Moonshine Mountain Cookies

Moonshine Mountain Cookies Contact Information

Email: [email protected]

You can also call or visit one of the store locations:

WEST HILLS
Phone: 865-240-4972
Address: 7343 Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37919

FARRAGUT
Phone: 865-357-5722
10205 Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37922


Final Thoughts

There’s no doubt about it – Moonshine Mountain is no ordinary cookie company. And that’s a good thing. From the packaging to the splash of moonshine to the delicious flavors, it’s evident that this company takes pride in their work.

Positives

  • Unique flavors & ingredients
  • Regular & rotating seasonal flavors
  • Hand-crafted with high-quality ingredients
  • Nationwide shipping
  • Make excellent gifts
  • Great customer reviews

Things to Consider

  • Some cookies contain alcohol
  • Most/all cookies have rolled oats
  • Shipping fees vary depending on location

From start to finish, we had a great overall experience working with the Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company. Without hesitation, we recommend you give them a try.

You may also enjoy: