35 Best Gourmet Mail Order Cookies To Buy Online

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Did you know some of the BEST mail order cookies in the country can be ordered online from gourmet bakeries and delivered right to your door?

The cookie companies on this list are baking up gourmet cookies that will blow your mind. From classic chocolate chip cookies and sugar cookies that taste homemade to one-pound mega stuffed cookies, the perfect cookie is just a click away.

Find The Best Gourmet Cookies Online

Who doesn’t love cookies with a big glass of milk? Whether you’re looking to order a dozen for yourself or a box to send as a gift to a cookie lover, you’ll find some fresh, bakery treats here that can ship nationwide from the best cookie companies in America.

To come up with this list, we polled our readers to get suggestions on the very best mail order cookies from bakeries coast to coast. We also did extensive research of our own on cookie delivery companies– which included lots of taste testing!

Insanely Awesome Bakery Cookies You Need In Your Life and Delivered To Your Doorstep

The Best Mail Order Cookies To Buy

Here are our top picks for the best cookies online and the best cookie delivery services to check out in 2022.

If you’re ready to send cookies to someone as a gift or order a treat for yourself, you’re sure to find the perfect gourmet cookies on this list.

Best Cookie Companies That Ship Nationwide

  1. Best Overall Cookie Company: West Coast Confection
  2. Most Gooey: Gooey On The Inside
  3. Best Custom Cookie Flavors: Big Fat Cookie
  4. Most Colorful: Baked In Color
  5. Best Cookies In A Tin: David’s Cookies
  6. Best Cookie Fries: The Cookie Joint
  7. Best Whoopie Pies: JL Cakes
  8. Best Southern Cookie: Christie Cookie Co
  9. Best Birthday Gift: Sugarwish
  10. Best Corporate Cookie Gifts: Mrs. Field’s
  11. Best Individually Wrapped: Feed Your Soul
  12. Best Cookie Bouquets: Cookies By Design
  13. Best Chocolate Chip Cookie: Jacques Torres Chocolate
  14. Best Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie: Levain Bakery
  15. Most New Cookie Flavors: Cravory Cookie
  16. Best Black & White Cookies: Famous 4th Street Cookie Co.
  17. Best Donut Cookies: Stan’s Donuts
  18. Best Bite-Size Cookies: Cookie Rich
  19. Biggest Cookie (5 pounds!): T-Rex Cookie Company
  20. Best Cookie Cake: Mini Melanie
  21. Best Rainbow Cookies: Zola Bakes
  22. Best Macarons: Macaron Queen
  23. Best Cookie To Support Troops: Operation Cookie
  24. Best Boozy Cookie: Moonshine Mountain
  25. #bestcookiesever: Wunderkeks
  26. Best OG Cookie Company: Blue Chip
  27. Best Hand-Decorated Cookies: Sugarica
  28. Best Organic Cookies: Bang Cookies
  29. Best Nut-Free Cookies: Baked Cravings
  30. Best Late Night Delivery: Insomnia Cookies
  31. Best Designer Cookie: Duchess Cookies
  32. Best Small Batch Cookies: Milk Jar
  33. Best PNW Cookies: Midnight Cookie
  34. Most Instagram-Worthy Cookies: Fat And Weird Cookie
  35. Fastest Growing Company: Crumbl Cookies

You may also like:
– Best Scones From Seven Sisters Bakery
Best Cookie Of The Month Clubs

1. West Coast Confection

Indulgent, gourmet, MASSIVE cookies, brownies and blondies. All of the treats are made with love, humor, hip-hop and high standards.

West Coast Confections Cookie Order Online
Image: West Coast Confection

We selected West Coast Confection as our number one pick for a few reasons. They aren’t the biggest cookie company or the most famous cookie company, but they are certainly one of the best in a field of really great options.

Their cookies are huge, delicious and packed with the most interesting flavors and textures. From the over-the-top treats to the creative flavor names to the fun attitude of the owners, the whole company is bursting with personality, making an order from West Coast a memorable experience.

These delectable treats are packed with flavor and come with fun names like:

  • Thicker Than a Bowl of Oatmeal: Fat and chewy oatmeal cookie is buttery and moist with a slightly golden-brown crust and sweet little plump raisins mixed throughout.
  • The Drake: Buttery. Thick. Gooey. Classic chocolate chip cookie.
  • Gansta’s Paradise: Peanut. Butta. Cookie. Traditional cookie dough base with peanut butter chips throughout.
  • That Dude: Extra gooey snickerdoodle cookie with white chocolate chips and a generous coating of cinnamon sugar.
  • Nu-Tellin Cookie: Nutella, a Ferrero-Rocher, and Hazelnut Oreos drizzled with chocolate.

West Coast also offers absolutely gigantic brownies and blondies. If you’re feeling creative, you can also build your own custom brownie creation. How cool is that!

You may also like: 15 Best Gourmet Brownies To Order Online

West Coast Confection Peanut Butter Brownie

How To Order Cookies Online From West Coast

To order cookies online from West Coast Confection, visit their website. You can use promo code SNACK10 to get 10% off your order online for cookie delivery with nationwide shipping.

A common question we hear is “Can I buy West Coast cookies near me?”
If you live in southern California, you’re in luck! You can buy locally at The Gym Vista (2128 Thibodo Ct, Vista, CA 92081) and at 619Muscle located inside The Gym SD (2949 Garnet Ave San Diego, CA 92109).

We recommend you call before you go to get details on availability. They are also known to frequent farmer’s markets and events from time to time. We’ve also heard a rumor that they are working on their very own retail location!

2. Gooey On The Inside

“New York City’s Best Ooey Gooey Cookies”

Gooey on the Inside Cookies
Credit: Gooey on the Inside
  • Birthday Cake
  • Dunkaroo
  • S’mores
  • Cap’n Crunch
  • Cuppa Joe
  • Chocolate Chunk

Also available are Goowees (cookie bites) and All Thing Jars (molten cookie & soft-baked dough) in a jar.

INSIDER TIP! Gooey On The Inside treats should always be eaten warm for maximum enjoyment. In fact, in the FAQs on the company website, they point out that their cookies were not designed to be eaten cold.

Gooey On The Inside Eat Cookies Warm Message
From Gooey On The Inside FAQs

How To Order Cookies Online

You can place an order for mail order cookies online on Goldbelly. Or check the Gooey On The Inside website for other ordering and cookie delivery options. The company is based in New York City.

A beast of a cookie! Huge, gooey, and extremely creative flavors. “If it can be put into a cookie, we can make it for you!”

Big Fat Cookie - Best Mail Order Cookies To Order Online
Image Credit: Big Fat Cookie
  • Quadruple Chocolate with Fluff
  • Marshmallow & S’mores
  • Peanut Butter Topped with Puppy Chow
  • Tons of over-the-top seasonal creations
  • Custom options: “If it can be put into a cookie, we can make it for you!”

Pro Tip: Warm cookies are the best. Big Fat Cookie suggests you heat n’ eat or slice n’ share these jumbo treats!

How To Order Cookies Online From Big Fat Cookie

You can order cookies online at Goldbelly for nationwide shipping.

Most Colorful Cookies

4. Baked In Color

Bright, colorful rainbow chocolate chip cookies. And who needs a box? These cookies come in a jar!

Baked In Color Cookies - Best Mail Order Cookies to Order Online
Image Credit: Baked In Color Cookies
  • Brookies: Brownie bottom, oreo inside and rainbow chocolate chip cookies top.
  • Stuffed Brookie Cakes: Fudge brownie bottom, chocolate chip cookie top and your favorite chocolate bar in the middle. Twix, KitKat, Reeses or 100K – you choose the inside!
  • S’more Cookie Cake: Graham cracker crust, marshmallow and milk chocolate chip inside and a massive rainbow cookie top, sprinkled with more marshmallows, graham crackers and chocolate chips.

There are also custom color options, corporate ordering and catering available.

How To Order Cookies Online From Baked In Color

You can order cookies online from Goldbelly for nationwide shipping.

Best Cookies In A Tin

5. David’s Cookies 

David’s has been shipping cookies since before shipping cookies was cool! They are best known for tins of fresh-baked cookies, cookie cakes and ready-to-bake dough.

David's Cookies Stack Tin

A few of the most popular flavors from David’s include classic chocolate chip, red velvet, white chocolate chip, cherry with white chip, rainbow candy, snickerdoodle and butter pecan meltaways.

David’s Cookie Dough comes in a variety of flavors like Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter, Snickerdoodle, Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip, and a super fun and colorful Play Cookie Dough.

Davids Cookies Play Cookie Dough
Credit: David’s Cookies

A wide variety of other delicious treats are also available including their famous rainbow cake that was featured on QVC.

Also check out their brownies, birthday cakes, cheesecake, cookie cakes, specialty holiday treats, gluten-free options and dessert of the month clubs.

David's Cookies Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

How To Order Cookies Online From David’s

To order David’s Cookies online for nationwide shipping, just visit their website or call their customer service department for more help.

Their signature Cookie Fry is a shortbread cookie cut to look like a crinkle-cut french fry. They come in a fun classic french fry package with a side of dipping sauce.

They were even featured on Oprah’s “O List” and the Cookie Fry was a secret ingredient on the Food Network show “Chopped”.

The Cookie Joint - Cookie Fries with dipping sauces
Image: The Cookie Joint

Cookie Fries come in basic flavors like shortbread, chocolate chip, double chocolate and confetti. Or you can also be more adventurous and choose something like cinnamon spice, cookies n’ cream, mint or chocolate toffee crunch.

Just like real fries, these cookie fries need a dipping sauce. You won’t find ketchup here. But you will find yummy sauces like marshmallow, salted caramel, hazelnut, peanut butter and chocolate.

How To Order Cookies From The Cookie Joint

Order cookies online for nationwide shipping from Goldbelly. Or visit The Cookie Joint website for retail locations in the Chicagoland area.

Special occasion baskets and gift cards are also available. These would be a fun choice for your next event too!

Best Whoopie Pies

7. JL Cakes

Home of New Hampshire’s Famous Whoopie Pie. More than a cookie and not quite a cake … it’s a whoopie pie!

Image: JL Cakes

Whoopie Pie Flavors

JL’s offers a wide selection of mouthwatering whoopie pie flavors that go way beyond classic vanilla and chocolate (although they offer both of those as well.)

Here are just a few of the yummy flavors listed:

  • Snickers Chunk
  • Maple Creme
  • Mint Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
  • Churro
  • Black Raspberry
  • Baklava
  • Cookie & Cream
  • and lots more

Another one of their fun offerings is the Snowball! It’s a small chocolate or vanilla cake, covered in fluffy coconut frosting and rolled in shredded coconut.

JL Cakes Snow Ball Cakes

How To Order From JL Cakes

Visit the JL Cakes website to order treats online for nationwide cookie delivery.

Based in Nashville, the Christie Cookie bakery was voted “Best Cookie in the South” by Southern Living Magazine.

Christie Cookie Co chocolate chip cookie
Credit: Christie Cookie Co

Christie Cookie Flavors

Christie Cookie Co offers 3 classic, signature flavors: chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia nut and oatmeal raisin. Each month they also offer a featured flavor made with the finest ingredients available.

Moist triple chocolate brownies can also be ordered separately or in combo cookie tins. They also offer their very own brand of dark, full-bodied Columbian coffee that pairs perfected with sweets.

How To Order Cookies From Christie Cookie Co

Order cookies online for nationwide delivery. Nashville store locations and information about local cookie delivery are also available on the Christie Cookie website.

Best Birthday Gift

9. Sugarwish

You pick the gift type (cookies, candy, popcorn, etc), and your recipient picks out the exact treats they want!

Sugarwish Cookie Gift Box
Source: Sugarwish

If you’re looking for a unique gift, this is it! There are plenty of gourmet food gift box options out there. But with Sugarwish, you pick the type of box to send. You can choose from cookies, popcorn, candy, snacks, coffee & tea, wine, and even dog treats.

Here’s the cool part. The person you’re sending the gift to gets to pick exactly what kind of goodies are sent in their box.

How To Order A Gift Online From Sugarwish

You can place an order online at the Sugarwish website. Order for yourself or have the gift delivered anywhere in the US. Be sure to use discount code MICKY7 for $7 off your Sugarwish order.

10. Mrs. Field’s

Gourmet cookies in classic flavors that are shipped nationwide in their famous red tin.

Mrs Fields Cookie Tin
Image: Mrs. Field’s

About Mrs. Field’s Cookie Gifts

Mrs. Fields offers an assortment of classic cookie flavors like chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, cinnamon sugar, white chocolate macadamia and frosted sugar cookies.

The cool thing though, is that you can customize your entire order. First, you select a tin (24 choices) or a basket (72 choices). Then you choose the exact assortment of cookies and brownies, select your ribbon and ship it off for nationwide delivery.

Also browse their website for a wide selection of gourmet gift options including brownies, cookie cakes, coffee cakes, chocolate-covered strawberries, decorated rice krispie treats and more.

Also, be sure to check out Mrs. Field’s brand new MEGA COOKIES. Each cookie is over 1/3 pound and they come in 3 flavors: Chocolate Chip, M&M Chocolate Chip and my personal favorite, Salted Caramel. Can’t stop eating them!

How To Order Cookie Gifts Online From Mrs. Field’s

You can order gift basekts and cookies online to ship across the country on Mrs. Field’s website. You can also call their customer service department for more help palcing your order.

Best Individually Wrapped Cookies

11. Feed Your Soul Bakery

Individually wrapped cookies (and bars) crafted with simple ingredients and a mission to give back. Each purchase helps feed those in need at the Coalition For the Homeless in NYC.

Feed Your Soul Bakery Box of Cookies

About Feed Your Soul Cookies and Bars

These delicious cookies have fun names like Cocoa Loco, Nutty By Nature, Sassy Molassy, Show Me the Honey and Drivin’ Me Coconuts. Each individually wrapped cookie is the perfect portion size.

The bars are equally tasty and creative with names like Unfudginbelievable, One Toff’ Blondies, Pardon My French Almond and Plant One On Me Vegan Brownies.

How To Place An Online Cookie Order With Feed Your Soul

You can place an order online for nationwide cookie delivery on the Feed Your Soul website.

Wholesale and bulk boxes of cookies and bars are also available for nationwide shipping.

You may also like: The 5 Best Bakeries To Buy Individually Wrapped Cookies

12. Cookies By Design

Cookies By Design is “The Original Cookie Bouquet Company”. They specialize in fresh-baked, hand-decorated sugar cookie arrangements and bouquets that are perfect for literally any holiday or occasion.

Cookies By Design Hand Decorated Cookie Bouquet
Image: Cookies By Design

Cookie Gifts From Cookies By Design

If you can dream up a cookie gift, Cookies By Design can probably create it for you. Their design options are extensive.

If you’re looking for a cookie arrangement, you can pick from a cookie bouquets, cookie gift basket and something called a boutray. It combines one of their signature sugar cookie bouquets with a tray of gourmet cookies to create a totally unique gift basket.

You can also get specialty cookies that come in a variety of packaging options and gift bundles such as boxes, tins, platters, and cookie baskets. They even have pro sports cookie gifts, custom photo cookies and cookie cakes.

And if you can’t find what you’re looking for from their standard offerings, they will personalize your cookie gift to your specifications. Get the custom message, colors or theme you need for your special event or occasion.

The company doesn’t stop at cookies. You can get all sorts of specialty sweets like gourmet brownies, cupcakes and chocolate truffles.

How To Order Cookie Gifts Online From Cookies By Design

You can visit the Cookies By Design website to place an order online for nationwide cookie delivery. You can also contact their customer service department for help with your order.

13. Jacques Torres Chocolate

A James Beard award-winning pastry chef crafts nostalgic chocolate treats, including the most perfect chocolate chip cookie in New York.

Jacques Torres World Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies
Source: Goldbelly

About Chocolate Chip Cookies From Jacques Torres

Jacques Torres is also known as “Mr. Chocolate”. In regards to his famous chocolate chip cookies, he has said “It’s a lot of chocolate with a little cookie dough around it.”

His giant cookies measure 5″ in diameter and are packed with his house blend of 60% dark chocolate baking discs.

How To Order Jacques Torres Cookies

The best way to buy Jaques Torres Cookies is to visit the Goldbelly to place an order online and have your cookies delivered.

Best Chocolate Chip Walnut

14. Levain Bakery

In 1995, Levain founders, Pam and Connie, created the ultimate chocolate chip walnut cookie to give them energy while training for a triathlon.

Today, they have 8 store locations and their world-famous cookies are shipped nationwide.

Levain Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookies Delivered
Source: Levain Bakery

About Levain Bakery Cookies

The cookie that started it all is Levain’s signature Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie. It’s crispy on the outside The inside is thick and gooey center filled with semi-sweet chocolate chips and walnut chunks.

Levain Bakery also sells other flavors like classic chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, dark chocolate and dark chocolate peanut butter cookies. We’ve tried them all – check out our Levain Bakery review here.

Levain Bakery Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

How To Order Levain Cookies Online

No need to travel to New York to get these tasty treats! You can place an order online on the Levain Bakery website for nationwide delivery of cookies by mail.

This bakery is known for its unconventional flavors. In fact, they have invented over 5,000 cookie flavors and introduce 6 new flavors each month!

Cravory Cookie New Unique Flavors
Source: Goldbelly

About Cravory Cookies

The Cravory’s cookies are crispy-on-the-outside and gooey-on-the-inside. They come in classic flavors like chocolate chip, birthday cake, and red velvet.

But their claim to fame is their inventive and creative flavors like the bright purple ube (yam) cookie, rosemary balsamic cookie, and pancakes & bacon cookie.

How To Order Cookies Online For Delivery From Cravory

You can place an order online on Goldbelly for nationwide cookie delivery.

Located inside Philadelphia’s popular Reading Terminal Market, Famous 4th Street Cookie Co. has been making sweet treats with all-natural ingredients since 1978. 

Famous 4th Street Black and White Cookies
Source: Goldbelly

About Black And White Cookies From Famous 4th

The black and white cookie is an iconic treat. Philadelphia’s most famous version of the Black & White Cookie can be found at Famous 4th Street Cookie Co. Their perfectly delicious black and white cookies are slathered in thick chocolate and vanilla fudge.

How To Order Famous 4th Cookies For Delivery

You can get Famous 4th Street cookies without a visit to Philly! Just place an order online on Goldbelly for nationwide cookie delivery. Each cookie comes individually wrapped.

Best Donut Cookies

17. Stan’s Donuts

The ultimate mash-up: these delicious hole-in-the-middle cookies are baked in donut pans!

Stans Donut Cookies
Source: Goldbelly

About Donut Cookies From Stan’s

Stan’s Donuts is best known for their donuts, but they ventured into cookie making with their amazing donut cookie! They use only the highest quality ingredients like European-style butter, cage-free eggs, and Belgian chocolate.

Their donut cookies come in flavors like Chi-Town Chunk, Snickerdoodle, Oatmeal-Raisin, and M&M.

How To Order Cookies for Delivery From Stan’s

Place an order online on Goldbelly for nationwide cookie delivery.

Best Bite Size Cookies

These fun and unique mini sandwich cookies were invented in 2020 and immediately took the world by storm!

Cookie Rich Bite Size Cookies
Source: Goldbelly

About Mini Cookies From Cookie Rich

These adorable bite-size cookies have two soft cookies which are sandwiched together with delicious fillings made with premium ingredients.

The high-end packaging makes for a top-notch gift. Believe it or not, you can even top your tiny cookies sandwiches with gold dust!

How To Order From Cookie Rich

To get your own mini cookies from Cookie Rich, just place an order online on Goldbelly for nationwide cookie delivery.

These gigantic 5-pound cookies are 16″ in diameter!

T-Rex Cookie Company Giant Cookie
Source: Goldbelly

About T-Rex Cookies

If the sheer size of these cookies isn’t impressive enough, they were also named ‘Best Cookie In America” by Time Out Magazine!

How To Ship Cookies Nationwide From T-Rex

You can place an order online on Goldbelly for nationwide cookie delivery.

20. Mini Melanie

These amazing cookie cakes are created by the winner of Food Network’s “Chopped”. Melanie took first place in an all-dessert, chocolate-themed episode of the show.

Mini Melanie Cookie Cake
Source: Goldbelly

About Mini Melanie Cookie Cakes

This deep-dish chocolate chip cookie cake has a thick, rich layer of chocolate ganache on top and even more mini cookies and chocolate chips on top.

How To Order Cookie Cakes Online

Place an order for Mini Melanie cookie cakes on Goldbelly for nationwide delivery.

See even more cookie cakes to order online.

Best Rainbow Cookies

21. Zola Bakes

Cookies fit for a unicorn! Neon colors, eye-catching chocolate drip, and glitter toppings.

Zola Bakes Rainbow Cookies
Source: Goldbelly

About Zola Bakes

These creative and colorful sweet treats will be the talk of any get-together. The bright colors, oozing chocolate and glittery sparkles make them perfect for a party!

How To Order Online From Zola Bakes

Place an order for Zola cookie cakes on Goldbelly for shipping nationwide.

Best Macarons

22. Macaron Queen

Premiere macaron delivery service offering Parisian macarons that are gluten-free and guilt-free. 

Macaron Queen Best Macarons To Order Online
Source: Macaron Queen

These gourmet macarons are specifically designed to use less sugar but still taste amazing. They are also made with almond flour and are 100% gluten-free.

Related: What Do Macarons Taste Like?

Macaron Queen Gourmet Cookies

Every macaron filling AND shell is packed with flavor and gorgeous color. Strawberry cheesecake, creme brulee, oreo, almond croissant, thin mint, champagne, blueberry citrus and passion fruit white chocolate are just a few of the amazing flavors.

They even have macarons for dogs! And for the humans in your life, they have tons of options for gift boxes and special occasions. If you’re looking for macaron gifts, be sure to check out these macaron cookbooks.

How To Order Macarons Online

Place an order online at the Macaron Queen website for delivery right to your door.

You may also like:
Why Are Macarons So Expensive?

23. Operation Cookies

Called the ”Best Cookies On Earth” by their customers, these sweet treats come with a 100% satisfaction guarantee! You won’t need it though.

Operation Cookies
Image Credit: Operation Cookies

About Operation Cookies

Operation Cookies was founded by Paul and Angie, a military couple with a passion for baking and service.

When Paul was deployed overseas, Angie made over 20 care packages and these weren’t your ordinary care packages. Each came with a separate theme in an oversized bankers box. They were stuffed full of goodies, treats, and of course – her homemade cookies.

Now that passion has become a business that gives back. They regularly send orders to active service members on deployment, as well as support the Wounded Warrior Project.

The flavor options are classic favorites like chocolate chip and peanut butter. They really don’t need any bells and whistles. They taste like recipes perfected over time – just like mom makes.

If you’re in the mood for delicious, homemade cookies that also support a great cause, then look no further. Operation Cookies is a winner in our book!

How To Order From Operation Cookies

You can place an order for cookies online for USA & APO/FPO shipping.

Best Boozy Cookies

24. Moonshine Mountain Cookie Company

Gourmet cookies with a splash of real moonshine!

Moonshine Mountain Cookies

About Alcohol-Infused Cookies

These gourmet cookies are made with a splash of moonshine, which gives them a unique flavor that has been praised by food critics and cookie lovers alike.

If you’re looking for an extra special treat, a memorable gift or even a corporate gift, take a look at Moonshine Mountain.

Be sure to also read our Moonshine Mountain Cookie review.

Cookie Delivery From Moonshine Mountain

Order cookies online at the Moonshine Mountain website to get these gourmet cookies delivered. And in case you’re shipping for a gift, be sure to let your recipient know they are infused with alcohol!


25. Wunderkeks

No Premixes, No Trans-Fats, No Preservatives – Just Great Cookies!

Wunderkeks Gourmet Cookies Online
Image credit: Wunderkeks

About Wunderkeks Cookies

Wunderkeks is known for its delicious chocolate chip cookies. But don’t overlook their other flavors like red velvet white chip, life-changing snickerdoodles, toffee and bright pink birthday cookie with sprinkles.

Order Wunderkeks Cookies Online For Delivery

To place an order for these delicious bakery cookies, head to the Wunderkeks website.

Best OG Cookie Company

26. Blue Chip Cookies

A Pioneer In Mail Order Cookies

About Blue Chip Cookies

Blue Chip Cookies has been in business for 40 years, making them one of the longest-running online cookie companies around. They were one of the first mail order cookie companies and have built a reputation for fresh, delicious cookies.

Blue Chip Cookies offers a wide variety of cookies, including classic chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin, as well as more unique flavors like lemon delight and berries & cream cookie.

With so many delicious options to choose from, it’s no wonder that Blue Chip Cookies has been a favorite among cookie lovers for decades.

Order Cookies Online For Delivery From Blue Chip

Visit the Blue Chip website to place an order online for gourmet cookie delivery.

Best Hand-Decorated Cookies

27. Sugarica Cookies

Gorgeous Hand-Decorated Gourmet Sugar Cookies

Sugarica Custom Logo Cookie Packaging
Image credit: Sugarica

About Sugarica Custom Cookies

Sugarica is a gourmet sugar cookie company that offers a wide variety of hand-decorated cookies. Their custom designs are intricate and beautiful, and their cookies are second to none.

Whether you’re looking for a special treat, logo cookies, a mother’s day surprise or a unique corporate gift, Sugarica has you covered.

Order Custom Gourmet Cookies Online From Sugarica

Visit the Sugarica website to browse the online cookie gallery for ideas and to place an order. If you’re looking to send cookies to someone, Sugarica carefully packages and ships cookies nationwide.

Best Organic Cookies

28. Bang Cookies

Giant, soft-baked luxury cookies using only organic and natural ingredients.

Bang Cookies - Best Mail Order Cookies To Order Online
Image: Bang Cookies

About Organic Cookies From Bang

If you’re looking for a cookie assortment, check out Bang Cookies. Just a few of their traditional flavors include Sea Salt Chocolate Chunk, Macadamia White Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk, Walnut Chocolate Chunk, Oatmeal Raisin and Triple Chocolate Chunk.

Other specialty flavors include Cinnamon Whiskey Crackle, S’mores, Rocky Road Peanut Chip and Pumpkin Spice Bourbon Crackle.

Bang Cookies Ordering Information

Order organic cookies online for shipping across the United States, local pickup and on-demand local delivery.

Be sure to use coupon code SNACK10 for 10% off your Bang Cookies order.

Best Nut-Free Cookies

29. Baked Cravings

100% Nut-Free, Peanut-Free & Tree-Nut Free Cookies

About Baked Cravings Cookies

These cookies are perfect for those with a sweet treat and nut allergy! All products from Baked Cravings, including cupcakes, cakes, muffins, popcorn and more, are totally nut-free.

If sesame is a concern, you’ll be happy to know that Baked Cravings products are totally sesame-free as well. Some dairy-free and vegan treats are available too.

Best Late Night Cookie Delivery

30. Insomnia Cookies

Delivery of Warm, Delicious Cookies Until The Wee Hours Of The Morning

Insomnia Cookies - Best Mail Order Cookies To Order Online
Image: Insomnia Cookies

About Insomnia Cookies

In addition to cookie flavors like double chocolate mint, peanut butter cup and s’mores, you can also get other sweet treats like cookie cakes, brownie, wiches (ice cream cookie sandwiches) and ice cream.

How To Order Insomnia Cookies For Shipping And Delivery

Insomnia Cookies has over100+ locations nationwide, so local pickup is an option for many. If you’re not near a store, you can still order cookies online for nationwide shiping and delivery.

Best Designer Cookie

31. Duchess Cookies

Home of the ‘Designer Cookie’

Duchess Bakery Cookie - Best Mail Order Cookies To Order Online
Image: Duchess Cookie

Cookie Flavors From Duchess Cookie

Some of the inventive options from Duchess Cookies include Cookie Monster, Unicorn, Oreo Cheesecake, Funfetti, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Oatmeal Apple Pie, Churro, Cherry Crumble, Peach Cobbler and Butterscotch Maple Bacon!

Duchess Cookies Near Me And Delivery

Duchess Cookies is located in New York, NY and offers local delivery and pickup at 2 locations. You can also order cookies online for nationwide shipping on their website.

Best Small Batch Cookies

32. Milk Jar Cookies

Homemade, hand-rolled cookies and baked fresh in small batches all day long.

Milk Jar Cookies - Best Mail Order Cookies To Order Online
Image: Milk Jar Cookies

About Milk Jar Cookies

Milk Jar is one of the most famous cookie companies thanks to their epic flavors like Banana Split, Birthday Cake, Milk & Cereal! They also have a cookie of the month club.

Milk Jar Cookies Near Me: If you’re in Los Angeles, you can grab a cookie that pairs perfectly with local sourced milk, ice cream and coffee. They offer local L.A. delivery and in-store pickup.

About Milk Jar Cookies

If you’re not in the LA area, you can order cookies online from Milk Jar.

Best PNW Cookie

33. Midnight Cookies

Half-pound cookies hand-crafted in the Pacific Northwest with free nationwide shipping

Midnight Cookies Funfetti - Best Gourmet Cookies To Order Online

About Midnight Cookies

You love fun flavors like Ch’Oreo Chip (a full Oreo baked inside a huge chocolate chip cookie), Funfetti (packed with white chips and sprinkles) and a variety of special seasonal and weekly flavors.

How To Order Midnight Cookies

You can order Midnight Cookies online for delivery, or stop in one for several Washington state locations.

Most Instagram-Worthy Cookies

34. Fat and Weird Cookie

These huge cookies come in creative and unique flavors that are perfect for sharing on social media.

Fat and Weird Cookies
Image: Fat and Weird Cookie

About Fat And Weird Cookies

The cookies are fat, the flavors are weird (and delicious!) and the Internet is obsessed with them! With over 200,000 Instagram fans, these gourmet cookies are a sight to behold.

How To Order Fat And Weird Cookies

Fat And Weird Cookie Location: 2540 Jenks Ave Panama City, FL 32405

You can place an order online for delivery, pick-up or nationwide shipping on the Fat and Weird website.

Fastest Growing Cookie Company

35. Crumbl Cookies

This fast-growing cookie franchise has captured America’s sweet tooth by offering a rotating weekly menu of flavors.

Crumbl Pink Sugar Cookie
Image: Crumbl Cookies

About Crumbl Cookies

Over the past few years, Crumbl Cookies has taken the US by storm. Over 500 Crumbl Cookie locations have popped up across the country. Their claim to fame is they create fresh-baked, gigantic cookies that come in creative flavors. They have a rotating menu of cookie flavors that change each week.

Crumbl Cookie Locations

You can browse all of the store locations by state and see some frequently asked questions about your visit here.

How To Order Crumbl Cookies

If you aren’t able to visit one of their bakery storefront locations (which we highly recommend you try!), you can also visit the Crumbl website to order cookies for local delivery or nationwide shipping.

You may also like:
50+ Best Copycat Crumbl Cookie Recipes
Copycat Crumbl Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe
Everything You Need To Know About The Crumbl Cookie Menu

Best Scones

Seven Sisters Scones

Okay, so scones aren’t technically the best mail order cookies … But they sure are delicious and totally underrated!

Seven Sisters Scones provide a modern take on scones with inventive flavors like Lemon Poppy, Cranberry Orange, Cherry Crumble, Lavender Honey, Fig & Goat Cheese and Bacon Cheddar Chive.

You can also order delicious cookies, bars, subscription boxes and gluten-free treats.

How To Order Scones Online

Order online from the Seven Sisters Scones website to get the best scones delivered to your doorstep.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where Can I Find Cookie Companies Near Me?

Many of the best cookie companies that ship on our list also have locations around the country. Here’s a quick list of names of cookie companies that may be near you.

  1. West Coast Confection: The Gym Vista (2128 Thibodo Ct, Vista, CA) and at 619Muscle located inside The Gym SD (2949 Garnet Ave San Diego, CA)
  2. Gooey On The Inside: 163 Chrystie Street, New York, New York
  3. Big Fat Cookie: 1030 North Hooker Street, Chicago, IL
  4. Levain Bakery: 8 locations in New York City, Brooklyn, Washington D.C., Boston and more
  5. Baked In Color: Butterfield Market in NYC. Also pick up in Scarsdale, NY.
  6. Crumbl Cookies Locations: 500+ stores across the US and growing. See the full store list.

We hope you enjoyed this list of the best cookie bakeries in America. From classic chocolate chip to gourmet macarons, the right cookie is out there for and waiting to be delivered to your door!

please consider sharing to PinterestInstagram and Facebook!

You may also enjoy:
Best Gourmet Food Gifts To Order Online

Best Custom Cookies To Order Online
Best Gourmet Brownies To Order Online

Best Cookie Cakes To Order Online
Best Birthday Cakes To Order Online
Best Cupcakes To Order Online
Best Cakes In A Jar To Order Online

Best Cookie Dough To Order Online

The Best Bakery Cookies Delivered Right To Doorstep

Micky Reed, a two-decade veteran in the food and baking industry, leverages her influential Three Snackateers food blog and Instagram presence to collaborate with industry giants like Ben & Jerry's and Crumbl Cookies. Her work has been featured on Delish, PopSugar and more. Her expertise as a product curator for one of the world's largest international snack subscription box companies solidifies her status as a key player in the field.

10 thoughts on “35 Best Gourmet Mail Order Cookies To Buy Online”

  1. Mouth-watering! You missed my favorite one though, chocolateandthechip.com has old-fashioned, chewy chocolate chip cookies for sale online.

  2. Thank you for Posting This. I love to send cookies to friends across the country. Last Year I did send cookies from Bang, Everybody loved them. Looks like with your help my research might be over. Stay Well

  3. Scones are most definitely not cookies! You left off heidisheavenlycookies.com! They are the best gourmet cookies I have ever tried!! Thanks for the list

  4. What a great article!! Thanks for focusing where to spend my $$. I got cookies from Big.Fat.Cookie and they are great. However, you have to buy pre-selected packages and have no control over what is in the packaged collection They are expensive and by the time you pay shipping, it’s too expensive not to be able to order what I want. Just can’t pay for a cookie flavor I don’t like. Next in line to try…Milk Jar and Bang!


Leave a Comment