12 Best Birthday Cakes To Order Online For Delivery

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

If you’re wondering where to order birthday cake online, you’ve come to the right place. In the list below, you’ll find some of the best birthday cake delivery services we’ve found.

It’s pretty convenient to get delicious birthday cakes delivered right to your door or to send a cake to be shipped nationwide to friends and family to celebrate their special day.

If you’re looking for gluten-free options, be sure to check out our list of gluten-free cakes for delivery and GF cookies too.

You may also like:
Best Gourmet Cookies To Order Online
Your Ultimate Guide To Crumbl Birthday Cookies: Rewards, Flavors & Recipes


Quick Read

Our top 5 recommendations for the best birthday cakes to order online are:
1. Best Variety Of Cake Flavors: Bake Me A Wish
2. Best Classic Birthday Cake: Magnolia Bakery
3. Best Layer Cakes: Milk Bar
4. Best Chocolate Birthday Cake: Daisy Cakes
5. Best Red Velvet Cake: Carousel Cakes

Keep reading below for more details on these top picks for cake delivery, plus several more options you’ll want to check out.


Another Cool Birthday Gift Idea!
With Sugarwish, you pick the type of box (cookies, candy, etc) and your recipient gets to select the exact treats they want to go in it. Use code MICKY7 for $7 off your order!

BEST VARIETY OF CAKE FLAVORS

Our Pick: Bake Me A Wish

Image: Bake Me A Wish

Bake Me A Wish is best known for its gourmet birthday cakes and bakery gifts that can be delivered overnight, nationwide. Each mail-order cake is delivered in a classy gift box with a greeting card.

This bakery doesn’t stop at traditional vanilla and chocolate birthday cake flavors. It’s the place to go if you’re looking for a wide range of cakes and flavor options. 

Here are just a few that may strike your fancy: Tiramisu, Salted Caramel, Tres Leches, Vesuvius (an Italian cake classic), Butterscotch Pudding, Limoncello, Boston Cream and Coconut Cream.

The confetti cake pictured above is my personal favorite. It features vanilla cake that is packed with rainbow sprinkles. You can read more in my review here.

Also Available from Bake Me A Wish: Cupcakes, cheesecakes, cookies, brownies, pies, gift towers and baskets.


BEST CLASSIC BIRTHDAY CAKES

Our Pick: Magnolia Bakery

Image: Magnolia Bakery

Magnolia Bakery captivated a worldwide audience after Carrie Bradshaw gushed about their cupcakes on the hit TV show Sex and the City.

If you good old-fashioned birthday cake, Magnolia is a great option. They take simple, classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate and carrot cake and make them phenomenal with high-quality ingredients. Each comes with an optional inscription such as Happy Birthday.

Also Available From Magnolia Bakery: World-famous banana pudding, the famous Carrie Cupcakes, brownies, cookies, cheesecakes, seasonal sweet treats and more.


Best layer CakeS

Our Pick: Milk Bar

Milk Bar Birthday Cake
Image: Milk Bar

Milk Bar is best known for its playful and innovative approach to classic desserts, using unexpected flavors and textures to create treats that are both delicious and memorable.

Their cakes have a distinctive naked frosting style, which has no outer frosting layer on the sides to showcase. the layers of cake and filling. The cakes are typically topped with another Milk Bar original – cake truffles!

Milk Bar cakes are a favorite for special occasions, particularly the iconic Birthday Cake, which is a funfetti-inspired vanilla cake layered with frosting and rainbow sprinkles.

Also Available from Milk Bar: Unique cookies like Compost (made with pretzels, potato chips, coffee, oats, and more), Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, and Confetti. And the infamous “Crack Pie,” a rich and buttery pie with a toasted oat crust.

Be sure to check out our Ultimate Guide To The Milk Bar Menu too.


BEST CHOCOLATE BIRTHDAY CAKE

Our Pick: Daisy Cakes

Daisy Cakes Best Chocolate Birthday Cake Delivered

Daisy Cakes has desserts so good they got a deal on Shark Tank!

Their classic chocolate cake is to die for. It has four layers of rich chocolate cake with chocolate ganache that is spread by hand. The entire cake is finished with a thick coating of fudge icing.

Also Available From Daisy’s: A ton of classic cake flavors plus “minikins” which are cakes in a jar. Birthday cake delivery is offered via Goldbelly.


BEST RED (AND BLUE!) VELVET CAKES

Image: Carousel Cakes

Carousel Cakes is home of Oprah’s Favorite Red Velvet Cake. She also called their Blue Velvet Cake “stupid good” and raved about the filling in their mousse cakes.

Also check out the “giggle cake” covered in sprinkles and filled with colorful buttercream. A few other interesting options are the Funnyfetti Cake (tons of sprinkles!), the Strawberry Crunch Parfait Cake, Baileys Cream Cake and Coconut Snowball Cake.

Also Available From Carousel Cakes: Cheesecakes, homestyle pies, cupcakes and seasonal/holiday dessert options. Online cake delivery is via Goldbelly.


BEST RAINBOW CAKE

Our Pick: David’s Cookies

Image: David’s Cookies

David’s Cookies is best known for its cookies to order online, but they offer lots more including cheesecakes, specialty desserts and of course, birthday cakes!

Rainbow cake is a birthday classic. It looks like a regular vanilla layer cake until you cut the first slice and reveal the fun, colorful red, orange, yellow, green and purple cake layers.

David’s has plenty of other cake flavors as well: Mile High Peanut Butter Explosion, Chocolate Overload, Milky Caramel Galaxy, Premier Pumpkin Spice and Chocolate Chip Deep Dish Cookie Cake to name a few.

Also Available from David’s Cookies: Cookies, brownies, cookie dough, cheesecakes, tarts, gluten-free and sugar-free treats and more.


CAN’T DECIDE WHICH CAKE TO TRY?
Why not try a Cake Subscription! With this subscription, you’ll receive hand-selected cakes delivered each month from the nation’s best bakeries.

BEST 2-TIER CAKES That Can Be Delivered

Our Pick: Carlo’s Bakery

Carlos Bakery Two Tier Cake For Delivery
Image: Carlo’s Bakery

Carlo’s Bakery, as featured on TLC’s Cake Boss, is known for over-the-top designer cakes as well as decadent pastries and desserts made by celebrity baker, Buddy Valastro.

Safely shipping a cake across the country is hard enough. Can you imagine shipping a two-tier cake? Well, Carlo’s can do it! Imagine the pleasant surprise when your special someone receives a tall two-tier cake for a super special birthday delivery! 

Also Available From Carlo’s: Black & white cookies, cannoli chips & dip, rainbow cookies, cupcakes and pastries. Cake delivery is via Goldbelly.


MOST FUN BIRTHDAY CAKES

Our Pick: Duff Goldman

Image: Duff Goldman Cakes

If you’re looking for a fun cake, you’ll love the creations from celebrity and fun-loving baker Duff Goldman from the hit show “Ace of Cakes“.

You can order an ever-chaning selection of Duff’s cakes by mail for nationwide shipping with Goldbelly.If you’re looking for a kid’s cake, check out the DIY cake kits which would be super fun for a birthday party!


MOST UNIQUE CAKES

Our Pick: PieCaken Bakeshop

Image: PieCaken

The PieCaken is a sight to behold. It is a crazy pie and cake mashup dessert that you can only order on Goldbelly.

The Original PieCake is available year-round. It features pecan pie, pumpkin pie, spice cake, and apple pie all layered together with cinnamon buttercream.

Besides the original PieCaken mentioned above, there are also seasonal, limited-edition desserts. Learn more about the seasonal PieCaken options here.

Check back on Goldbelly often to see the latest seasonal offerings for nationwide shipping and delivery.


Celebrity Favorite Cakes

Our Pick: We Take The Cake

Image: We Take The Cake

Based in Fort Lauderdale, We Take The Cake is a custom cake shop often visited by celebrities and luxury caterers. Their famous key lime bundt cake is one of Oprah’s Favorite Things. 

Quality and attention to detail are what sets this cake shop apart from the competition. They use ingredients like whole buttermilk, fresh eggs and real butter. Experienced bakers mix every batter and frosting by hand. 

This bakery knows that shipping a birthday cake is all about presentation. They go the extra mile with hand-decorated cakes and custom-designed packaging to make sure your birthday cake delivery is perfect.


Our Pick: Mrs. Fields

Image: Mrs. Field’s

Not everyone is a cake fan. We can respect that! That’s why we included Mrs. Field’s Giant Cookie Cakes in our list.

Each giant chocolate chip cookie cake measures 12 inches in diameter. These colossal cookie cakes are moist, chewy and made with real butter, whole eggs, and pure vanilla.

For ease of ordering, there are a variety of pre-set Happy Birthday designs. However, you can also customize your message and frosting colors. 

Also Available from Mrs. Fields: Brownies, chocolate-covered berries, decorated rice krispie treats, coffee cakes, nut-free sweets and more are also available for delivery.


MOST COLORFUL CAKES CAKES

Our Pick: Baked in Color

Credit: Baked in Color

As their name suggests, COLOR is the name of the game at this fun bakery. Made with super colorful dough, these huge rainbow cookie cakes are rolled and twisted to create a unique sweet treat.

In addition to the classic Rainbow Chocolate Chip, other flavors include Brownie Oreo, Funfetti Cookie and Cookies N’ Cream. There is even an option to choose your own colors. 

Also Available from Baked In Color: Choose Your Own Color Cookie Gift Tins, College Colors Cookie Gifts and Giant Rainbow Oreo Brownies.


FAQs About Ordering Cakes Online

Q. Why Should I Use A Birthday Cake Delivery Service?

One big reason to try an online cake store is simply that you’ll have access to the very best cakes from across the United States. Ordering online and using a delivery service is the best way to try all the delicious treats bakeries around the country have to offer.

Q. What is the best cake shop that offers cake to order online?

Each of the bakeries in this list was carefully chosen and made the cut as the best online cake shops. In the list, you’ll find a perfect gift to ship to a loved one or to order for your next party. If you’re still undecided, you may also want to consider some companies that ship the best birthday cupcakes.

Q. Can I order cake online for other occasions?

A. Absolutely! The bakeries on our list make fantastic birthday cakes for sure. But the best part is they also offer cakes for other occasions. You’ll find cake options for everything from baby showers, wedding cakes and for holidays like Valentine’s Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas and more.


Who do you think has the best cakes you can order online? Leave a comment below!

The Best Places To Order Birthday Cake Online

Micky Reed, a two-decade veteran in the food and baking industry, leverages her influential Three Snackateers food blog and Instagram presence to collaborate with industry giants like Ben & Jerry's and Crumbl Cookies. Her work has been featured on Delish, PopSugar and more. Her expertise as a product curator for one of the world's largest international snack subscription box companies solidifies her status as a key player in the field.

Leave a Comment