The 5 Best Bakeries To Buy Individually Wrapped Cookies

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Imagine the look on your loved one’s face when they open a box of freshly baked, gourmet cookies. Or, maybe you want to send a special thank you to a client with a delicious treat. Whatever the occasion, there’s nothing like receiving a box of gourmet cookies.

But where do you find the best individually wrapped cookies? Never fear, we’ve done the legwork for you and compiled a list of the best places to buy gourmet cookies online.

All of these bakeries offer sweet treats that are individually packaged, making them perfect for grabbing on the go or giving as a gift. Each company also offers online ordering with nationwide shipping and delivery.

Here’s a quick list of our top 5 picks for cookie companies that offer individually wrapped cookies.

  1. Best Gourmet CookiesLevain Bakery
  2. Best Bulk OrdersMrs. Field’s
  3. Best Company MissionFeed Your Soul
  4. Most Creative FlavorsWest Coast Confection
  5. Best Black & White CookiesFamous 4th Street Cookie Co

Keep reading below for more details on each of these gourmet cookie companies, plus a few extra bakeries for you to check out.

Best Bakeries To Buy Individually Wrapped Cookies

You may also like:
27 Best Cookies Of The Month Clubs & Subscription Boxes
35 Best Gourmet Mail Order Cookies To Buy Online
The Best Cookie Cakes For Delivery

Your Best Individually Wrapped Cookie Options

1. Levain Bakery

Levain Bakery is a New York City institution, known for its massive cookies that are so good, that they’ve received glowing reviews from places like Food & Wine magazine and the New York Times.

Levain Bakery Cookie Review From Food & Wine

Their gourmet cookies normally come with 4 treats in an elegantly wrapped cellophane bag that is tied with a ribbon.

Flavor options include chocolate chip walnut, two chip chocolate chip (semi-sweet and dark chips), dark chocolate chip, dark chocolate peanut butter chip and oatmeal raisin.

In 2023, they also added a new vegan & gluten-free chocolate chip walnut cookie to the line-up.

You can check out our Levain Bakery review here.

Individually Wrapped Cookies From Levain Bakery

You can also order individually wrapped cookies for an event like weddings, birthdays, graduations, retirements and corporate gifts.

Individual Wrapped Chocolate Cookie From Levain Bakery

Place your order online and have cookies delivered anywhere in the U.S.

2. Mrs. Field’s

Mrs. Field’s is another well-known name in the world of gourmet cookies. If you’re looking to buy delicious cookies in bulk, you’ll want to check out their case of 100 individually wrapped cookies.

Mrs Fields Individually Wrapped Cookies in Box
Image: Mrs. Field’s

Each gourmet bakery cookie is baked fresh and then packaged individually for freshness and convenience.

These pre-packaged cookies are perfect for a company picnic, corporate gifts, Christmas gifts for staff, or even school treats and teacher gifts.

Mrs Fields Individually Wrapped Cookies Review

Visit Mrs. Field’s website to order cookies online for nationwide shipping. They also have a great selection of other treats like brownies, cookie cakes, corporate gifts, gift baskets and lots more.

3. Feed your Soul

Feed Your Soul is a company founded on purpose, passion, and of course, sweet treats! They are on a mission to make the world a sweeter place through their delicious treats and by giving back.

As of 2021, Feed Your Soul has donated over 25,000 cookies, served over 25,000 meals, fed 185,000 people and contributed almost a quarter million dollars. That’s a lot of goodness!

They’ve been featured on Today, Forbes and The New York Times to name a few.

Feed Your Soul Bakery Box of Cookies

All cookies from Feed Your Soul are individually wrapped for optimal freshness. Their cookies come in loads of flavors like Key Lime, Lemonberry, Cocoa Loco, Show Me The Honey, Snickerdoodle and more.

Feed your Soul Lemonberry Cookie

You’ll also want to check out their individually wrapped bars too. They come in fun flavors and have even more fun names like Unfudginbelievable Brownies, Pardon My French Almond Bars and Plant One On Me Vegan Brownies.

Feed Your Soul Blondie Brownie Bar

You can buy cookies online at the Feed Your Soul website for nationwide delivery.

4. West Coast Confection

West Coast Confection is one of our personal favorites. They are a gourmet cookie company based in San Diego, CA that specializes in gigantic cookies and brownies in over-the-top flavor combinations.

Sometimes you’ll even find a brownie that’s topped with a full-size cookie or one that has cookies baked inside … or both!

West Coast Confections Brownie Topped With A Cookie

The treats from West Coast are so massive, that packaging them individually is pretty much the only way to go.

Huge Cookies From West Coast Confections
Image: West Coast Confection

For nationwide delivery, head to the West Coast website and place an order online for cookies and brownies. You’ll also see an option to place an order for a totally custom cookie or brownie creation!

5. Famous 4th Street Cookie Co

Famous 4th Street is a Philadelphia institution known for its Black & White cookies that ship nationwide on Goldbelly.

Box of Famous 4th Street Individually Packaged Black and White Cookies

These delicious B&W cookies are round black and white cookies slathered in a layer of rich, thick chocolate and vanilla fudge.

Each 3″ cookie is individually packaged with a Famous 4th Street label on the front.

Even More Individually Wrapped Cookie Options

If you didn’t find what you were looking for in the list above, here are a few more cookie companies that offer individually wrapped cookies.

Bell’s Cookie Co

With Bell’s, you can choose your own custom cookie assortment. Pick from classic flavors like Chocolate Chunk with Maldon Salt, Red Velvet, Snickerdoodle and Confetti.

Or go for a more adventurous option like Columbian Corn, Lemon Blueberry Shortbread or The Bells (it has potato chips!)

Gooey On The Inside

Gooey On The Inside is a gourmet cookie company that specializes in creative, indulgent cookie flavors like Dunkaroo, Banana Cream, Fruity Pebbles Cheese Cake and lots more!

Each cookie weighs in at 5.5 ounces and comes in a resealable bag to enjoy later. You can buy Gooey On The Inside’s gourmet cookies online from Goldbelly.

Cookies By Design

Cookies By Design is a national chain of bakeries specializing in decorated sugar cookies. Their claim to fame is their unique Cookie Bouquet.

They also offer a really great selection of corporate gifts including individually wrapped cookies, cookie tins and logo cookies.


Etsy is an online marketplace where you can find just about anything – including gourmet cookies. There are dozens of talented bakers selling their goodies on Etsy, so you’re sure to find the perfect individualized gift (or treat for yourself !)

We also love shopping on Etsy because it’s a great way to support small businesses.

As you can see, when it comes to buying cookies that are wrapped separately, you’ve got plenty of options.

As a quick recap, here are the 5 best cookie companies that we’ve personally tried and recommend.

Best Gourmet CookiesLevain Bakery
Best Bulk OrdersMrs. Field’s
Best Company MissionFeed Your Soul
Most Creative FlavorsWest Coast Confection
Best Black & White CookiesFamous 4th Street Cookie Co

Up Next:
50+ Best Copycat Crumbl Cookie Recipes

Meet Micky Reed, your go-to snack expert and creator of The Three Snackateers—a hub for all the best sweets and treats to make, try, and buy. From whipping up collaborations with industry giants like Ben & Jerry's to being featured on Delish and PopSugar, Micky's delicious adventures are causing a stir in the foodie world. You can find Micky on IG and Pinterest.

4 thoughts on “The 5 Best Bakeries To Buy Individually Wrapped Cookies”

Comments are closed.