7 Best Cupcakes In A Jar To Order Online

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Part cupcake, part trifle, and completely adorable cupcakes in a jar are the latest dessert craze to hit the bakery scene. And it’s no surprise why!

These sweet treats include ready-to-eat decadent layers of cake and rich frosting, plus other goodies like sprinkles and chocolate chips. Each comes in its own little jar, so they are great to ship and look super cute right out of the box.

Here you’ll find our expert reviews and tips for how to choose the best cake jars to order online.


Quick Read

Here’s a quick view of our top 3 recommendations for the best cupcakes in a jar.
1. Wicked Good Cupcakes (featured on Shark Tank!)
2. Jars By Dani
3. Brooklyn Cupcake
Keep reading below for our complete list of recommendations.


Looking for regular cupcakes to order online?
Check out our recommendations for the best gourmet cupcake companies that ship nationwide.

Cupcakes In A Jar To Order Online

Cupcake Jars: The Top Bakeries to Place an Online Order for Nationwide Delivery

The companies in the list below are some of the best in the country for shipping delicious cupcakes in a jar.

1. Wicked Good Cupcakes

Wicked Good Cupcake Jar Flavors

These wickedly tasty jarred cupcakes became popular after being featured on Shark Tank. The company was started by a mother-daughter team, and has been growing rapidly since appearing on the show.

Their layered cupcakes are packaged in mason jars and have all kinds of yummy and cute toppings like sprinkles, confetti, and more.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Flavors

They offer decadent versions of your favorite cupcake classics, including chocolate and vanilla birthday, red velvet, salted caramel, cookies and cream, and s’mores. You’ll also find plenty of limited-time, seasonal flavors throughout the year.

They also recently launched a new line of bite-size brownies too!


2. Jars By Dani

jars by dani cupcakes in a jar
Credit: jars by Dani

These ultra-hip dessert jars are packed with brightly colored layers of moist cake, frosting, and extra sweet goodies like sprinkles and chocolate chips.

Originally a social media sensation in New York, you can now purchase Dani’s cupcakes in a jar via Goldbelly and have them shipped nationally.

The jars are available in mini 4 oz. and regular 8 oz. sizes. Flavors include white chocolate, fudge brownie, cake batter, cookie dough, and strawberry shortcake, plus a big selection of seasonal flavors.

There are also vegan and gluten-free options in many flavors.


3. Brooklyn Cupcake

Brooklyn Cupcake Cupcakes In A Jar
Image: Brooklyn Cupcake

The founders of Brooklyn Cupcake have combined inspiration from their Puerto Rican and Italian backgrounds to create amazingly inventive and scrumptious desserts.

They’ve been named “Best Cupcake in New York” and featured by several media outlets, and now have their award-winning goodies available to be shipped nationally from Goldbelly.

While they sell a variety of baked goods, the adorable (and functional) cupcake jars are just right for shipping.

In addition to traditional flavors, Brooklyn Cupcake also offers fun flavors like banana pudding, Samoa (yup, like the GirlScout cookie), French toast, and Bacardi Coquito. A few of the varieties are also available as vegan.


4. Baked Cravings

Baked Cravings Cupcakes In A Jar 6 pack
Credit: Baked Cravings

This Best of Manhattan Award-Winning bakery in New York City is known for its great selection of treats specially made for those with allergies and specific dietary needs. Their bakeries are 100% nut-free and peanut-free, and they offer gluten-free and vegan cake-in-a-jar options.

Choose from their standard selections like vanilla and chocolate, or check out the specialty line of Cravers cupcakes with decadent flavors like cookies and cream, red velvet, and vegan apple cinnamon.

Or take it to the next level with the Infused line of cupcakes, which includes boozy treats like Tiramisu Patron, Cognac Cupcakes, Caramel Vodka Cupcakes and more.


5. Angel Food Bakery

Angel Food Bakery Cupcake In a Jar
Image: Angel Food Bakery

Called the “coolest urban bakery in the country” by Thrillist, Angel Food Bakery is best known as the home of the donut cake. Their treats are creative, whimsical and perfect for celebrating nearly any occasion.

Their Lazy Cake Jars are made with layers of crumbled cake, frosting, and fruit compote or chocolate ganache. Each jar is prepared as two servings, so they are great to share or save a bit for later to enjoy (mhm, sure).

Lazy Cake Jars are available in flavors like confetti sprinkle birthday cake, death by chocolate, peanut butter, salted caramel, strawberry birthday cake and raspberry chocolate chip.


6. 4 Rivers Smokehouse

4 Rivers BBQ Pudding In A Jar
Image: 4 Rivers BBQ

A smokehouse might not be what you think of when reviewing the best cupcakes in a jar. But hear us out. 4 Rivers Smokehouse is changing up the cupcake world with its perfectly layered pudding jars.

Some include cake, others have sections of graham cracker, and all include rich pudding and whipped cream on top. These decadent desserts are prepared to serve 6 per jar, so each is like its own little party.

There are plenty of flavors to choose from like banana dream, key lime pie and Reese’s.


7. Etsy

Not only can you find custom and handmade gifts on Etsy, but it’s also a great site to shop for some delicious cupcake jars. And as a bonus, you’re often supporting a small business too. Win-win!

You can browse by keyword (like vegan and gluten-free), choose a specific delivery area, and add a price range to find exactly what you need. And there are also lots of customization options, like sprinkles to match your occasion’s theme colors or personalized stickers on the jars.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What is a cupcake in a jar?

Think of a classic cupcake, with a tender cakey main body and topped with icing. Now take two of those treats, stack them on top of each other, and stick ’em in a jar. That’s it basically it!

Cupcakes in jars are layered with cake, frosting, and sometimes other cupcake garnishes like chocolate shavings, nuts, and sprinkles. They’re best eaten with a fork or spoon straight from their individual containers.

How do you ship cupcakes in a jar?

They are usually shipped expedited to ensure a fresh, moist and delicious treat. Some companies allow you to choose from different shipping options too. Insulated packages are often used and will usually contain dry ice or ice packs as well.

How long do cupcakes in a jar last?

Your order will arrive ready to eat, but you may wish to save some for later. Each bakery is different but cakes in jars typically last up to 3 weeks in the fridge, and about 3 months in the freezer.

What cupcake company was on Shark Tank?

Wicked Good Cupcake! They also happen to be our top pick. Also, be sure to check out our article on the Coolest Shark Tank Foods You Can Order Online.

Micky Reed, a two-decade veteran in the food and baking industry, leverages her influential Three Snackateers food blog and Instagram presence to collaborate with industry giants like Ben & Jerry's and Crumbl Cookies. Her work has been featured on Delish, PopSugar and more. Her expertise as a product curator for one of the world's largest international snack subscription box companies solidifies her status as a key player in the field.