Wicked Good Cupcakes Review

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Everyone loves cupcakes. Wicked Good Cupcakes takes our beloved cupcakes and kicks them up a notch by stuffing them in a jar and shipping them across the country right to your door. That’s right, it’s a cupcake in a jar!

About Wicked Good Cupcakes

Each cupcake in a jar from Wicked Good Cupcakes is hand-packed and has layers of moist cake, delicious frosting, and other fillings. But pace yourself, because each jar is the equivalent of about 2 cupcakes.

Another really cool feature of Wicked Good Cupcakes is that they last up to 10 days WITHOUT refrigeration. If you don’t gobble them up by then, you can freeze them right in the jar for up to 6 months.

Because these treats come in durable glass jars, they are a great product to ship. In fact, the company does ship anywhere in the United States.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Feature

Who owns Wicked Good Cupcakes?

Mother-daughter duo Tracey Noonan and Danielle Vilagie started Wicked Good Cupcakes in 2010 as a way to spend more time together. Fueled by their passion for sweets the business grew quickly. In 2011, they opened their first store in Cohasset, Massachusetts.

But that was just the beginning…

Wicked Good Cupakes On Shark Tank

As news spread nationwide of their innovative cupcake in a jar idea, another twist of fate skyrocketed their business. In 2013, they showed their product to millions of people when they were featured on season 4 of the ABC hit TV show, Shark Tank.

Shark Tank investor, Kevin O’Leary (also known as Mr. Wonderful) was smitten with their product. They received a $75,000 investment and the rest is history. For good reason, sales boomed after their appearance on the show.

Since then they’ve moved into a larger facility, opened new locations, and sold millions of jars filled with cake to happy customers across the country. They even named a flavor after O’Leary called Mr. Wonderful’s Cookie Butter.

In 2021, Wicked Good Cupcakes was acquired by Hickory Farms.


Wicked Good Cupcake Flavors

Wicked Good offers both traditional and gluten-free flavors. At the time of writing, the available flavors were as shown in the list below.

However, please keep in mind, there is no guarantee these same flavors will be available for you. The company changes up its offerings frequently including fun seasonal flavors like the lemon flavor you’ll see in my review below.

Traditional Cupcake Flavors

  • Chocolate Birthday (chocolate cake and frosting)
  • Marble Mutt (chocolate and vanilla cakes and frostings)
  • Reverse Chocolate Birthday (chocolate cake with vanilla frosting)
  • Chocolate Lab (chocolate cake, ganache and frosting)
  • Mr. Wonderful’s Cookie Butter (cinnamon cake, caramel and cookie butter frosting)
  • Reverse Vanilla Birthday (vanilla cake, chocolate frosting, sprinkles)
  • Chocolate Salted Caramel (chocolate cake, caramel sauce and frosting)
  • Sea Salted Caramel (vanilla cake, caramel sauce and frosting)
  • Cookies & Cream (vanilla cake and buttercream with Oreo cookies)
  • Wicked Good (“cookie-like” peanut butter & chocolate chip layers with PB frosting and ganache)
  • Gimme S’more (chocolate cake, graham crackers, ganache and marshmallow)
  • National (Security) Velvet (red velvet cake, cream cream frosting)
  • Peanut Butter Surprise (chocolate cake, peanut butter frosting, fudge icing)
  • Vanilla Birthday (vanilla cake and frosting with sprinkles)

Gluten-free Cupcake Flavors

  • Chocolate Lab
  • Flourless Chocolate and Peanut Butter Brownie
  • Reverse Vanilla Birthday
  • Cookies and Cream
  • Reverse Chocolate Birthday
  • Sea Salted Caramel

You can see the full and current flavor listing here.


Wicked Good Cupcakes Review

I sampled six Wicked Good Cupcakes flavors. Check out the details below for my thoughts on each flavor.

VANILLA BIRTHDAY

Let’s start with the classic Vanilla Birthday flavor. This is everything you love about birthday cake in one perfect bite.

Delicious, moist vanilla cake paired with vanilla buttercream and tons of colorful sprinkles.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Vanilla Cupcake in A Jar Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Vanilla Birthday Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes Vanilla Birthday Cake In A Jar
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Vanilla Birthday Flavor

REVERSE CHOCOLATE BIRTHDAY

If you prefer chocolate birthday cake, this one is for you. It’s just like the Vanilla Birthday flavor, except with chocolate cake instead of vanilla.

The cake is a rich chocolate flavor and is a great complement to the sweet vanilla frosting.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Chocolate Birthday Cake Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Reverse Chocolate Birthday Flavor
Chocolate Cake In A Jar Wicked Good Cupcakes
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Reverse Chocolate Birthday Flavor

MR. WONDERFUL’S COOKIE BUTTER

This flavor packs a punch! With cinnamon cake, a layer of caramel plus cookie butter frosting, it has a lot going on.

It’s fun to try each layer separately and then as one big bite. Each flavor is a star on its own, but also comes together as a really harmonious bite.

I took my time sampling this one. The flavors are strong, so just a couple bites at a time was enough to satisfy my sweet tooth.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Mr Wonderfuls Cookie Butter Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes Shark Tank – Mr. Wonderful’s Cookie Butter
Mr Wonderful Cookie Butter Cupcake In A Jar Shark Tank
Wicked Good Cupcakes Shark Tank – Mr. Wonderful’s Cookie Butter

SEA SALTED CARAMEL

I’m pretty picky when it comes to my salted caramel. Wicked Good’s salted caramel flavor passed my test with flying colors.

The caramel is thick, buttery and bold with just the perfect undercurrent of saltiness.

I kept going back for more and more of this flavor.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Sea Salt Caramel Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Sea Salted Caramel
Sea Salted Caramel Cake In A Jar Wicked Good Cupcakes
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Sea Salted Caramel

COOKIES N CREAM

The cookies and cream vibe in this flavor is epic. I was super impressed with the sheer amount of cookie in this flavor.

There are big chunks of Oreo cookie as well as a fair amount of finer crumbles for great texture contrast.

The vanilla cake and buttercream pair perfectly with the Oreo. I was a big fan of this flavor.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Cookies N Cream Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Cookies N Cream
Wicked Good Cupcake In A Jar Cookies N Cream
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Cookies N Cream

WHOLE LOTTA LEMON

This seasonal jar was a nice light flavor perfect for summer. It was well balanced – not too sweet, not too tart.

While tasty, I felt the other flavors I tried had more visual appeal. Digging through to find the sprinkles, thick caramel swirls or cookie chunks is part of the fun. This jar was more simple with just layers of cake and frosting.

Wicked Good Cupcakes Lemon Cake In A Jar Flavor
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Whole Lotta Lemon
Lemon Cake In Jar Wicked Good Cupcake
Wicked Good Cupcakes – Whole Lotta Lemon

Frequently Asked Questions about Wicked Good Cupcakes

How long do wicked good cupcakes last?

Wicked Good Cupcakes last up to 10 days without refrigeration. The company recommends enjoying the treats within 7 days of receiving them.

Refrigeration does not extend the shelf life. They should be kept in a cool, dry place.

Pie jars can be refrigerated for up to 2 weeks.

Does Wicked Good Cupcakes have a promo code or coupon code?

The company occasionally offers special events or promotions. At the time of this writing, no promo codes were available.

However, you can create a Wicked Good account to earn “Wicked Good Dollars” to use toward purchases.

How much do Wicked Good Cupcakes cost?

At the time of writing this article, a custom 6-pack of cupcakes in a jar was around $60.00. This included ground shipping. Each jar is equivalent to about 2 standard cupcakes making a 6-pack approximately the same as a dozen cupcakes.

Who owns Wicked Good Cupcakes?

Wicked Good Cupcakes was founded by mother-daughter duo Tracey Noonan and Danielle Vilagie.

What episode is Wicked Good Cupcakes on Shark Tank?

Wicked Good Cupcakes was featured on season 4 of Shark Tank (2013).

Who invested in Wicked Good Cupcakes?

Shark Tank investor, Kevin O’Leary (also known as Mr. Wonderful) invested in Wicked Good Cupcakes.

Where did Wicked Good Cupcakes start?

The first store was in Cohasset, Massachusetts.

Can you freeze Wicked Good Cupcakes?

Yes, Wicked Good Cupcakes can be frozen for up to 6 months.


Final Thoughts

Wicked Good Cupcakes are a really fun way to get your cupcake fix. Of course, there are always lots of considerations before making a decision to buy. Here are our final thoughts.

PROS
– Unique product
– Can ship nationwide
– Excellent flavor selection
– High-quality product
– Makes a great gift
– Corporate, wedding & event options
– Gluten-free options

CONSIDERATIONS
– Price & shipping costs
– Frostings contain cream cheese
– Made in a facility with nuts

Bottom line: I definitely recommend giving Wicked Good Cupcakes a try for a special treat for yourself or as a gift. I don’t think you’ll be disappointed!