Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe

This classic Cookie Monster Ice Cream recipe makes the BEST signature blue ice cream you know and love! It is loaded with Oreos and chocolate chip cookies and is homemade with an easy no-churn method that doesn’t require any cooking.

WHAT IS COOKIE MONSTER ICE CREAM FLAVOR?

Because of its bright blue color, the first question often asked about Cookie Monster ice cream is What does it taste like? Well, the ice cream base itself is a simple and delicious vanilla flavor. That’s it! Blue food coloring is used to create the fun, bold hue of the beloved Cookie Monster from Sesame Street. Then chunks of cookies are folded into the vanilla ice cream base to add crunchy textures and lots of yummy, chocolatey goodness.

Vanilla Extract vs Vanilla Paste: What’s the Difference?

Vanilla extract is good for adding a hint of vanilla essence to a dish.  However, for a vanilla-based recipe such as this one I highly recommend using vanilla paste.  It is concentrated and therefore has a much stronger flavor that is delicious in ice cream.

1

NGREDIENTS FOR HOMEMADE COOKIE MONSTER ICE CREAM

– Heavy whipping cream – Sweetened condensed milk – Vanilla paste or extract – Double Stuf Oreos – Chips Ahoy or any other preferred packaged chocolate chip cookies – Blue food coloring – Salt

Get the full recipe -  TAP below!