Select Page

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read our disclosure policy for more information.

Good Humor Reese’s Bars Review

Good Humor Reese’s Bars Review

The official product description is a “frozen dessert bar blended with Reese’s peanut butter sauce and covered in signature Good Humor cake coating.” The hardcore ice creamers out there seem to get really upset when the ingredients are anything except ‘premium, full-fat ice cream’.  However, I am open to all desserts you find in the freezer no matter how they self-identify.  Frozen yogurt, low-fat ice cream, frozen dessert bars … doesn’t matter, I’m all in! But for this review, I’m just gonna call them ice cream bars, ok?

Reeses Good Humor Ice Cream Bar Closeup

Like other Good Humor Bars, these Reese’s bars have the classic cake coating on the outside. The crumble here is black and white in color and looks a lot like crushed up Oreos. It gives the bar a nice crunchy component and brings in the chocolate flavor.

The inside is a very light brown color and is very creamy, almost fluffy. It’s got a really nice peanut butter flavor that holds it’s own against the chocolate.  I often find that one ingredient overpowers – like in the recent Peanut Butter Chocolate Pebbles. The chocolate was so strong, you could barely detect the peanut butter.  Definitely not the case here. These ice cream bars have a nice balance.

I believe the folks at Good Humor when they say these are made with REAL Reees’s Peanut Butter Swirl. But I’ll be honest, if they used a different type of peanut butter, I would have no idea.  It’s not like you’re biting into a frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup here. It’s just a good peanut butter and chocolate ice cream bar.

So in conclusion, if you like peanut butter and you like ice cream bars, you’ll probably enjoy these.

Would I buy it again: Yes! They also have other flavors: Oreo, Strawberry Shortcake, Chocolate Eclair, Toasted Almond and Birthday Cake.

Would I eat it again if offered to me?  Absolutely!

Rating: 4/5

Price: $3.98

Store: Walmart




About The Author


Confession: I’m obsessed with snacks. I have been for as long as I can remember. Ask anyone that knows me for a fun fact and the word ‘cupcake’ will probably come up. I’m known to keep sprinkles in my purse because you never know when the occasion may call for them. I always look at the dessert menu before ordering dinner. For fun I love to spend hours in the grocery stores scouting new and interesting foods. I love baking, but hate cooking. And I’m so lucky that my husband and little girl love sweets as much as I do!

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read our disclosure policy for more information.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Favorite Finds

Candy Club


Work With Us

We would love to hear your partnership ideas to create amazing content for our readers who love snacks, treats and sweets!

Learn More

30 Creative Hot Chocolate Mix-Ins - Three Snackateers


Sign up now for 30 easy and delicious ideas!

Thanks for joining us! Please check your email for your free download.

Pin It on Pinterest