11 Best Mail-Order Ice Creams For Nationwide Delivery in 2022

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Do your local stores not have a great ice cream selection?

Have you visited somewhere and fallen in love with an amazing regional ice cream company?

Do you have friends or family that live far away that you’d love to surprise with a totally delicious and unexpected gift?

Or maybe you just want to try all of the amazing ice cream options available nationwide?

The answer to all these questions is to order the best ice cream online and have it delivered right to your door (or the door of anyone across the US)!

Best Ice Cream To Order Online For Delivery

If you’d like to jump right to the best gourmet ice creams for delivery that we recommend, here’s a quick list of our top 3 picks.

  1. Capannari Ice Cream
  2. Nick’s Ice Cream
  3. Nightfood

If you’re ready to dive in and get the scoop on all of our recommendations for the mail order best ice creams, keep on reading below.

1. Capannari Ice Cream

Super-premium ice cream named one of the best in America

Capannari Black Raspberry Chip Ice Cream
Image: Capannari

Capannari Ice Cream is so good, it was touted by the Chicago Magazine as the best in Chicago. Good Morning America named it one of the top 10 “Best Scoops in America”. And Bon Appetit honored their ice cream as a “top pick.”

You can choose from a wide range of flavors, including classic Vanilla and Chocolate, or go for more adventurous options like black raspberry chip, malted butter fudge and gooey brownie batter.

Capannari has a scoop shop in Mount Pleasant, Illinois where you can stop in for a tasty treat. If you’re not planning a visit to the area, you’re still in luck.

Another great way to get Campannari is to order through Goldbelly. And while you’re shopping on Goldbelly, you can also conveniently grab some cookies, cakes, brownies or pie to go with your ice cream!


2. Nick’s Ice Cream

Creamy, Swedish-style ice cream that is both delicious AND healthy

Nick's Ice Cream

Not many brands can make a rich, creamy and tasty ice cream that is actually good for you. But Nick’s has done it!

It’s true – Nick’s Ice Cream is both delicious and healthy. Their Swedish-style ice cream is light and creamy, yet low-fat, low-calorie and keto-friendly.

Still skeptical? Check out our in-depth Nick’s Ice Cream review with lots of photos and details on some of their most popular flavors.

Nick’s offers a pretty big selection of ice cream treats including:

  • Light Ice Cream (16+ flavors)
  • Vegan Ice Cream (7+ flavors)
  • Keto Snack Bars
  • Cookie Kräms (Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches)
  • Seasonal Flavors
  • Product Bundles like Chocolate Lover’s, Best Sellers, Vegan and Keto Friendly

The flavors options are plentiful and they all have Swedish-inspired names like Cookies and Kram (cookies and cream), Salta Karamell (salted caramel) and Swedish Vanilj (vanilla).


3. Nightfood 

Ice cream specially formulated by sleep experts for nighttime snacking

Nightfood Ice Cream
Image: Nightfood

There’s a new player in the market of delivering the best ice cream right to your doorstep, and it goes by the name of Nightfood.

This company delivers ice cream that satisfies your late-night sweet tooth, but won’t keep you awake with a sugar buzz.

Nightfood’s team of sleep and nutrition experts designed the ice cream to be sleep-friendly for healthier night snacking. In a pint you’ll get:

  • Less sugar, less fat and fewer calories
  • Protein, fiber and digestive enzymes
  • Sleep-friendly tryptophan (it’s the same stuff that makes you sleepy after Thanksgiving dinner!)
  • Magnesium, B6
  • No artificial sweetners or eythritol

Savor the flavors like Cookies N’ Dreams and Cherry Eclipse and then drift off to dreamland. They even have a Pickles For Two flavor to satisfy those crazy pregnancy cravings!


4. Alec’s Ice Cream

Organic, clean-label ice cream made with simple ingredients you can pronounce.

Alecs Ice Cream Honey Blueberry Lavender Flavor
Image: Alecs Ice Cream

On a quest to make the best ice cream around, Alec’s Ice Cream went back to the basics. Their fresh take on French custard-style ice cream uses the least amount of ingredients for the maximum amount of flavor.

Their organic, clean-label ice creams are made with simple ingredients you can actually pronounce like raw cane sugar and free-range egg yolks. You won’t find any artificial preservatives, flavors, or colors.

Alec’s Ice Cream is family-owned and operated. They source milk and cream from a local family farm that has been in the same location for over 100 years. The dairy is as fresh as you can get. It’s delivered to the creamery twice daily!

Choose from amazing flavors including honey blueberry lavender and salted caramel latte.


5. Ecreamery Ice Cream

Create your own personalized ice cream gift

eCreamery Ice Cream Shark Tank Food

eCreamery is the place to go for an awesome personalized ice cream gift. Choose from dozens of delicious flavors, then customize your pints with your very own label.

You’ll also want to check out the Flavor of the Month Club and special occasion collections designed especially for events like birthdays, get well, sympathy, and just because!

We personally love eCreamery, but it’s also worth mentioning that the company was featured on Shark Tank once, so you know it has to be good!

And if you use code SNACK10, you can get 10% off your order.


6. Salt & Straw Ice Cream

Daringly delicious ice cream crafted with unthinkable care

Salt & Straw Ice Cream Pints
Image: Salt & Straw Ice Cream

Salt & Straw has a huge online following and loyal fanbase thanks in part to their awesome, creative flavors.

If flavors like chocolate caramel potato chip cupcake and buttermilk pancakes, bacon & eggs don’t get your attention, I don’t know what will!

You can also join their Pints Club for monthly shipments of seasonal or vegan flavors.


7. Graeter’s Ice Cream

Graeter's Ice Cream
Image: Graeter’s Ice Cream

Rich, custard-like ice cream perfected over 150 years

Graeter’s Ice Cream is one brand that will make you appreciate the craft of making truly great ice cream.

This Cincinnati-based, family-owned business has been around for over 150 years and still churns out delicious flavors of ice cream. They use the world’s only French Pot Freezer to create rich, custard-like ice cream in dozens of delicious flavors.

And all those years of experience have also helped Graeter’s create an amazing new product line called Perfect Indulgence. Believe it or not, it’s animal-free dairy!

Graeter’s is available for online ordering and nationwide delivery through Goldbelly.


8. Life Raft Treats

Not your average ice cream treats!

Life Raft Treats Not Fried Chicken Ice Cream Treat
Image: Life Raft Treats

Life Raft Treats sells a variety of innovative and tasty ice cream treats. The one that caught our attention is the Not Fried Chicken Ice Cream Bucket.

It’s one of the most popular items on the menu, and it’s no wonder why. This treat looks exactly like a fried chicken drumstick.

But when you take a bite, you’ll be delighted to bite into waffle ice cream, a chocolate-covered cookie “bone” and a sweet white chocolate coating that holds the crushed cornflake coating in place.

Life Raft Treats are available for online ordering and nationwide delivery through Goldbelly.


9. Tipsy Scoop boozy ice cream

Get a buzz with your brain freeze!

Tipsy Scoop Boozy Ice Cream
Image: Tipsy Scoop

These boozy ice creams combine artisanal, handmade ice cream with delicious mixed cocktails. Each pint contains up to 5% alcohol by volume.

Some of the mouthwatering flavors include Raspberry Limoncello Sorbet, Cake Batter Vodka Martini, and Blueberry Margarita.

Tipsy Scoop has generated quite a buzz with features in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, USA Today, Oprah magazine and lots more.

Tipsy Scoop Boozy Ice Cream is available for online ordering and nationwide delivery through Goldbelly.


10. Nightingale Ice Cream

Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches Birthday Cake Flavor
Image: Nightingale Ice Cream

This online ice cream store offers a modern take on the classic ice cream sandwich. While you can get classic chocolate and vanilla, you’ll definitely want to check out all of the other innovative flavor combos.

Birthday cake, fat banana, salted caramel, key lime pie, orange creamsicle, banana pudding … the list goes on and on!

Nightingale Ice Cream is available for online ordering and nationwide delivery through Goldbelly.


11. A La Mode Ice Cream

Allergy-friendly ice cream totally free of nuts, eggs and sesame

A La Mode Allergy Friendly Ice Cream No Nuts
Image: a la mode

Ice cream is often an elusive fantasy for folks with allergies, but that’s no longer the case. A La Mode is completely free of nuts (peanuts, tree nuts including coconut) egg and sesame.

With flavors like Partly Cloudy (blue cotton candy ice cream with mini marshmallows and a color-changing spoon), kids with allergies can still join in the fun.

And don’t worry – there are plenty of other flavors – like pumpkin spice and apple pie – for more sophisticated palates too.

Nightingale Ice Cream is available for online ordering and nationwide delivery through Goldbelly.


Final Thoughts

Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or want to explore new territory, there is something for everyone in this list of the best ice cream to order online. So, what are you waiting for? Get your sweet tooth fix today by ordering one (or all!) of these delicious ice creams online.

If you enjoyed this article, save it for later on PinterestInstagram and Facebook. Also join our Facebook Group for more snack fun!

Best Ice Cream To Order Online For Delivery